'the giRl with the needle' Review

By Nadia Dalimonte

Vic Carmen Sonne in The Girl with the Needle

Expressionist horror and realism collide to eerie effect in Magnus von Horn’s The Girl with the Needle, a devastating gothic tale that looks into the faces of pain. The chilling distorted images in the film’s first few minutes set a bleak tone for the moral darkness we’re about to be immersed into. While based on Danish criminal activity from the 1910s and 20s, the story does not play out as a biopic by any means. Magnus von Horn follows the disintegrating threads of an unemployed, pregnant woman abandoned by patriarchal upholding in post-WWI Copenhagen. Isolated and left to her own devices, her hope fades in the shadows of unrelenting desperation. She finds herself under the wing of someone who will do anything not to believe the world is a horrible place, even if it means creating a distorted reality of buried morals. From the immersive setting to the haunting characters, the film confronts narrow paths of survival for women living on society’s fringes.

The central story follows Karoline (Vic Carmen Sonne), a young seamstress navigating loneliness and isolation as her husband Peter (Besir Zeciri) has been declared missing on the frontlines. She finds a spark of relief in Jørgen (Joachim Fjelstrup), a wealthy gentleman who owns the textiles factory she works at. As this new relationship unfolds, Peter returns from the war with a severely disfigured face. Despite not answering any of her letters, he expects his marriage to Karoline is still intact. But she rejects him, an act made even colder by the knowledge that society too will reject him. “Look at what the war spat out.” He’ll be reduced to a freak show in a carnival act, faded in the hands of a cruel world.

When Karoline becomes pregnant, she and Jørgen plan to marry. They pay a visit to his mother, who completely disapproves of the relationship due to their disparity in social class. The cowardly Jørgen obeys, and to make matters worse, Karoline is fired from the factory. In a matter of minutes, the gentle protection Karoline once felt in Jørgen’s arms is disillusioned. The heartbreaking misfortune leaves her in a harsh reality: she has a baby on the way, and does not have a home nor a job to speak of. She barely has enough money to afford rent.

Evil preys on vulnerability such as this. What sorts of atrocities are human beings capable of when they succumb to desperation? How far will the innocent fall to escape poverty? Karoline’s bleak future leads her to a bathhouse, where she attempts to terminate the pregnancy. This puts her in the path of Dagmar (Trine Dyrholm) and her daughter Erena (Avo Knox Martin). Dagmar is a candy shop owner who uses the storefront to run a secret adoption agency, offering foster homes for mothers’ unwanted infants. To make ends meet, Karoline gives up her baby and becomes a wet nurse for Dagmar.

A seemingly innocent arrangement grows sinister as Karoline becomes privy to disturbing acts of violence. The once-empowering bond between two women fighting for survival collapses before our very eyes. Their characters depict two different explorations of self-determination and independence in a patriarchal world. Set in the horrific aftermath of war, the film unfolds around uncomfortable everyday decisions women make out of necessity. They believe they are doing the right thing, not just for themselves but for their children’s futures. To watch the diminishing of such futures in this film is an unsettling experience that haunts you and shakes you to the core.

Magnus von Horn has made a true-crime nightmare. While set decades into the past, his layered gothic vision echoes with modern resonance. With bold and empathetic direction, he confronts themes of morality, survival, and reproductive rights from the perspective of a woman essentially left to die. Karoline represents the plight of so many women whose unjust communities continuously fail them, and who are then punished for taking matters drastically into their own hands. The character’s hardship becomes our anchor into the mind of a serial killer, which adds powerful layers of guilt and innocence to the storytelling. Karoline personifies the women Dagmar believes she is saving. The restrained direction by von Horn makes time for you to really grasp how the characters’ moralities twist out of shape.

In this shadowy blend of horror and realism, the tremendous performances by Vic Carmen Sonne and Trine Dyrholm shine. Sonne’s bold facial expressions and vulnerability hypnotize you into her character’s inner turmoil. She balances the harshness with glimmers of hope, which the film masterfully maps out and ends on for her. Dyrholm has a more ambiguous role to play in the narrative, as her intentions are not clearly laid out but rather stumbled upon. To convey the despicable, the unthinkable, the unfathomable, on screen and still retain some semblance of humanity is a tall order. Dyrholm’s commanding presence instills you with security and solidarity before turning her back on both of those safety blankets, conveying disturbing motivations underneath.

The visuals also play an integral part in creating a sense of perpetual moral doom. Cinematographer Michal Dymek shoots distorted expressionist faces and isolated figures cloaked in shadows. He excels at framing interiors and capturing stark lighting through a black-and-white lens. The black-and-white imagery is an effective choice that makes the story feel all the more bleak, contrasting the disturbing grey areas of humanity. Each and every frame of The Girl with the Needle builds dread, as do the reverberating notes of Frederikke Hoffmeier’s score, the stark details of Jagna Dobesz’s production design, and the measured patience of Agnieszka Glinska’s editing.

From the eerie atmosphere and haunting performances to the thematic resonance and subjective perspective, The Girl with the Needle has the hallmarks of both a gothic fable and a true-crime story. With such unforgettable subject matter and artistic expression, it would be a surprise not to see Denmark’s Oscar selection in the race for Best International Feature. Each and every element of this film looks unflinchingly into the face of pain and questions its origins, while remembering that even in the face of cruelty from a ground level, there is still hope in this world.

The Girl with the Needle is a MUBI release and will be in select theaters on December 6.